260 hysterical
opinions

Tuesday, 26th November 2002, 11:28am
An opinion by: Rascal
 My Sister's Hand in Mine

My Sister's Hand in Mine by Jane Bowles

Hey, Jane Bowles is a good writer, just like they all said. After reading her biography I began to wonder if all the fuss was warranted, considering the woman only finished one novel and one play, and spent the rest of her creative life crossing out, re-writing, and crossing out again. But you can really hear the results of her unceasing and crushing searches for her words. The book Two Serious Ladies, conveys a dual story of the subtle struggles and conflicts that two aquaintances each experiences in their respective quests. One stumbles upon love, and the other seeks a form of personal salvation from her peaceful existence of implacable self-sufficiency. Not that I relate to this at all.

I can see why the New York Times Book Review called her one of the finest "modern" writers, there is something terribly modern about the spare precision of Bowles' language.

Her play In The Summer House is even better, if you ask me. Apparently it didn't do so well when it hit Broadway in the early 1950's and I would dearly like to know why. She does a dang good job of portraying her characters, consisting largely of a number of mother-daughter sets, with emphasis on the relationship between a particular duo. The tension of the drama lies in the fact that one of the most sympathetic characters is also possibly a murderess, and while we wait to know for certain, we hope more fervently for her happiness. It's effective as a hidden crux, around which all the characters act. The extremely cool ending keeps this secret; while cracking open the door on yet another, older secret. We are left only with a distinct impression:maybe, probably, which works perfectly given the morally ambiguous ground on which these women walk.

There are ten more pieces which basically comprise the sum total of Bowles' writing. Most of these are short stories and a few are chunks from what were intended to be longer works. I'll gripe here about the few scraps of writing under the section "From The Notebooks". It makes for rather a weak finish to the book, and seems pathetic, as if her completed works aren't enough... Maybe they would have been better sprinkled in between the other works, like intermissions. That's not Jane's fault though.




Readers have left 1 comments

If anyone needs to work on their style your reviewer would be a good place to start. "Dang good job..." ???? Maybe some revision would be in order here. Also, did your biographer happen to mention that JB lost the majority of her mss. in taxis? I got it from Paul in Tangier in 1993. Get real!
Bernie on Monday, 25th February 2002, 2:10am

Leave a comment

name
email (if you want to be notified)
   <-- Please retype the word you see here:
Notify me when someone replies to this post?

Buy this item

 Buy “My Sister's Hand in Mine” from amazon.com or amazon.ca

Email/print/translate this article!

print this opinion

Recent opinions in fiction  

Recent opinions by Rascal

A River Sutra by Gita Mehta
all the Anxious girls on earth by Zsuzsi Gartner
An Equal Music by Vikram Seth
Babel Tower by A.S. Byatt
Backpack by Emily Barr