260 hysterical
opinions

Wednesday, 27th November 2002, 6:44pm
An opinion by: Rascal
 

Lily Brisco: A Self-Portrait by Mary Meigs

I recognized the author photo on the back cover as one of the women who appears in the low-key yet most enjoyable film The Company of Women. Watch it if you get a chance, it's a documentation of what happens when eight older women who are strangers to eachother, get on an old schoolbus and drive out to a country house for a short holiday. Mary Meigs, it turns out, was the maker of this movie.

Lily Briscoe is subtitled as an autobiography and Meigs' first book. To be super-accurate, it's more of a memoir, each chapter comprising a quiet, thoughtful essay on critical elements in the author's life. She writes of her childhood in a very proper and moneyed family, first in Philadelphia, and later in the social arch-circles of Washington DC. She writes about relationships and love triangles with U.S. writer/activist Barbara Deming and Canadian writer Marie-Claire Blais. She writes of significant friendships with artists and writers - their emotional effect on her, their reactions to her own work as a painter, their reactions to and with eachother. Like the movie The Company of Women this book is low key and enjoyable - if not quite as charming because we are stuck inside one woman's head instead of being in the amusing position of voyeur to a wider social dynamic.

In general, I admired Meigs' clarity and honesty, while I completely related to her acute sensitivity, which seemed to contribute so much discomfort to her emotional life. It's not easy to get these subtleties of feeling down in writing. She describes a tense aspect of her friendship with writer Mary McCarthy and husband Bowden Broadwater:

    "Their kindness to me had a double edge; it was a concern for my welfare, but it contained within it the plain suggestion that my welfare consisted in following their advice.

    I had the feeling not only that they thought I was infinitely malleable, but also, that I wanted to be transformed by them; it was as if they were fitting a ghostly skin over me that I could not shake off. A conversation comes back to me. They were discussing my choice of a smoke-grey sleeveless dress of pleated chiffon. "You've decided to become the kind of person who wears that kind of dress," said Bowden. "You've chosen your type." Everything surged up in me in protest; it was all wrong, this analysis. He had put the cart before the horse. I had chosen the dress, I explained, not in order to define myself, but because I liked it. "Exactly!" cried Bowden triumphantly, and my insides began to churn with a familiar turmoil. I couldn't bear it when people squeezed me into corners, reduced me to clichés. I had enough trouble supporting the severity of my own self-analysis and didn't need any outside help."

These last italics are mine. I'll just bet that this sentence applies to a ton of women.




Readers have left 1 comments

I am writing to inform you that your information in the first paragraph about Mary Meigs is incorrect. The title of the film is "The Company of Strangers" and it is about seven elderly women (between the ages of 65 - 88) and one younger woman (27) who does not have the same type of role as the elderly women (she is the bus driver and the viewer does not learn about her personal life as they do the other women). Additionally, the paragraph states that these women drive out to an old house for a vacation when in reality, they are on a bus tour and the bus breaks down and they seek refuge in this house.
I hope you will utilize this information to provide accurate information to your readers about Mary Meigs.

Sincerely,
C Kennedy
C Kennedy on Monday, 25th February 2002, 2:10am

Leave a comment

name
email (if you want to be notified)
   <-- Please retype the word you see here:
Notify me when someone replies to this post?

Buy this item

 Buy “Lily Brisco: A Self-Portrait” from amazon.com or amazon.ca

Email/print/translate this article!

print this opinion

Recent opinions in people  

Recent opinions by Rascal

A Death in Brazil: A Book of Omissions by Peter Robb
A Little Original Sin - The Life and Work of Jane Bowles by Millicent Dillon
Albany Park by Patrice Chaplin
Anais Nin, A Biography by Deirdre Bair
Another City by Patrice Chaplin