Wednesday, 27th November 2002, 9:49pm
An opinion by: Rascal
 The Woman Warrior

The Woman Warrior - memoirs of a girlhood among ghosts by Maxine Hong Kingston

Today there is Amy Tan, but first there was Maxine Hong Kingston, it would seem. The Warrior Woman was first published in 1976, way before the experiences of the ABC (American Born Chinese) was brought to general public attention by Tan's novels such as the The Joy Luck Club, and The Kitchen God's Wife.

Aptly subtitled "memoirs of a girlhood among ghosts", Hong Kingston has accomplished something really effective in her approach to her material - somehow walking a line between memory and fiction. This is appropriate in relating a miasma of unspoken rules and metaphorical explanations that governs much in Chinese culture and language (Excuse my enormous generalization, I'm speaking from my own 4 year experience in parts of South East Asia). The author grows up among the "ghosts", her mother's term for white Americans, as well as the ghosts of her culture of origin. I was impressed with the way she captured something so elementally different between her parents' culture and her school culture. An example is given in the final chapter "A Song for a Barbarian Reed Pipe":

    "From the configurations of food my mother set out, we kids had to infer the holidays. She did not whip us up with holiday anticipation or explain. You only remembered that perhaps a year ago you had eaten monk's food, or that there was meat, and it was a meat holiday...How can Chinese keep any traditions at all? They don't even make you pay attention, slipping in a ceremony and clearing the table before the children notice specialness. The adults get mad, evasive, and shut you up if you ask. You get no warning you shouldn't wear a white ribbon in your hair until they hit you and give you a sideways glare for the rest of the day... But I think that if you don't figure it out, it's all right. Then you can grow up bothered by neither 'ghosts nor deities.' 'Gods you avoid won't hurt you.' I don't see how they kept up a continuous culture for five thousand years."

It really is so like that!

The book is organized in five long chapters. Other chapter-stories are about the perished, shameful, un-name-able aunt back in China; the tale of the Woman Warrior, folk-hero and long-ago liberator of the Han people of China; "Shaman", about her mother's medical career in China, before she joined her husband in the U.S.; and the reunion of another aunt with her americanized husband, after 20 years separation. Good stuff.




Readers have left 6 comments

The Woman Warrior is a worthless book that no person should ever be subjected to reading
rkw25 on Monday, 25th February 2002, 3:58pm
I think you read that book by mistake, you should have read "Green eggs and Ham" by Dr. Seuss...maybe thats alittle more to your understanding.  The extensiveness in culturalism and symbolism in this book partakes a great deal of people.  From your opinion you must not be from a culturally sound family... :0
RCN on Tuesday, 30th July 2002, 2:46pm
hogwash. Rkw simply stated an opinion. You can't possibly make some objective statement about understanding of this book based on that. From a literary perspective (especially dealing with narrative structure and intrusion) this is a VERY difficult piece. I know grad students who struggle mightily with it. I think you might want to check out a dictionary before you go accusing other's of a lack of understanding as evidenced by your use of the word 'partakes'. And how does an opinion have anything to do with someone being from a 'culturally sound' family. What in the heck is that anyway? A bit vague, RCN, to say the least. This book is hard--beautiful in places, as with the entire scene in Shaman dealing with the horrors the mother faces (the baby without an anus...) and ending with the endearing scene between Kingston and her mother. Most of "White Tigers" is a beautifully written piece of poetic prose. But this book is hard...and in places it reads like disjointed pscyho-babble.
Aiglos on Wednesday, 16th November 2005, 2:06am
rkw25, you are being extremely close minded. and RCN does a crappy job of explaining how they feel about it. Thanks Aiglos.
I personally had to read this book for my senior project in AP English, and while i'm still figuring out parts of it, i'm glad i picked this book. It has shown me things about a different culture that i never would have bothered to find out on my own, and it's so rich in material to use in my project...
Katelin on Wednesday, 23rd April 2008, 10:35pm
Though I didn't enjoy this book, I found this book to be interesting, yet very dense and difficult. I never read Chinese-American literature before reading this.
Matt on Thursday, 11th September 2008, 1:10pm
I read this book for school and it was up there on the list of books to never read. You guys all rip this RKW for no reason. This book can only be of interest to older people in my opinion (in comparison to my age that is.) When i read this book, i read it with an open mind and tried to enjoy it to its full extent...its impossible. This book is the farthest thing from interesting.
B-Fresh on Monday, 12th October 2009, 10:00pm

Leave a comment

name
email (if you want to be notified)
   <-- Please retype the word you see here:
Notify me when someone replies to this post?

Buy this item

 Buy “The Woman Warrior - memoirs of a girlhood among ghosts” from amazon.com or amazon.ca

Email/print/translate this article!

print this opinion

Recent opinions in identity  

Recent opinions by Rascal

A Mother's World, journeys of the heart by Marybeth Bond and Pamela Michael (editors)
Bone Black, Memories of Girlhood by Bell Hooks
Caucasia by Danzy Senna
Discovery of Heaven by Harry Mulisch
Face by Aimee E. Liu